From: Kidney transplant outcomes in HIV-positive patients: a systematic review and meta-analysis
Author (refs.) | Representativeness of the exposed cohort | Selection of the non-exposed cohort | Ascertainment of exposure | Outcome of interest not present at start | Comparability: age and sex | Comparability: other factors | Assessment of outcome | Follow-up long enough | Adequacy of follow-up | Total NOS score | Study quality |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Roland [48] | 1 ● | 0 ○ | 1 ● | 1 ● | 0 ○ | 0 ○ | 1 ● | 1 ● | 1 ● | 6 | Fair |
Touzot [31] | 1 ● | 0 ○ | 1 ● | 1 ● | 0 ○ | 0 ○ | 1 ● | 1 ● | 1 ● | 6 | Fair |
Mazuecos [49] | 1 ● | 0 ○ | 1 ● | 1 ● | 0 ○ | 0 ○ | 1 ● | 1 ● | 1 ● | 6 | Fair |
Stock [50] | 1 ● | 0 ○ | 1 ● | 1 ● | 0 ○ | 0 ○ | 1 ● | 1 ● | 1 ● | 6 | Fair |
Stock [4] | 1 ● | 0 ○ | 1 ● | 1 ● | 0 ○ | 0 ○ | 1 ● | 1 ● | 1 ● | 6 | Fair |
Kumar [51] | 1 ● | 0 ○ | 1 ● | 1 ● | 0 ○ | 0 ○ | 1 ● | 1 ● | 1 ● | 6 | Fair |
Qiu [52] | 1 ● | 1 ● | 1 ● | 1 ● | 0 ○ | 0 ○ | 1 ● | 1 ● | 1 ● | 7 | Fair |
Tan [53] | 1 ● | 0 ○ | 1 ● | 1 ● | 0 ○ | 0 ○ | 1 ● | 1 ● | 1 ● | 6 | Fair |
Carter [54] | 1 ● | 0 ○ | 1 ● | 1 ● | 0 ○ | 0 ○ | 1 ● | 1 ● | 1 ● | 6 | Fair |
Gruber [55] | 1 ● | 0 ○ | 1 ● | 1 ● | 0 ○ | 0 ○ | 1 ● | 1 ● | 1 ● | 6 | Fair |
Gómez [56] | 1 ● | 0 ○ | 1 ● | 1 ● | 0 ○ | 0 ○ | 1 ● | 1 ● | 1 ● | 6 | Fair |
Izzo [17] | 1 ● | 0 ○ | 1 ● | 1 ● | 0 ○ | 0 ○ | 1 ● | 1 ● | 1 ● | 6 | Fair |
Roland [57] | 1 ● | 0 ○ | 1 ● | 1 ● | 0 ○ | 0 ○ | 1 ● | 1 ● | 1 ● | 6 | Fair |
Gasser [58] | 1 ● | 0 ○ | 1 ● | 1 ● | 0 ○ | 0 ○ | 1 ● | 1 ● | 1 ● | 6 | Fair |
Gathogo [10] | 1 ● | 1 ● | 1 ● | 1 ● | 0 ○ | 1 ● | 1 ● | 1 ● | 1 ● | 8 | Good |
Baisi [59] | 1 ● | 0 ○ | 1 ● | 1 ● | 0 ○ | 0 ○ | 1 ● | 1 ● | 1 ● | 6 | Fair |
Xia [20] | 1 ● | 1 ● | 1 ● | 1 ● | 1 ● | 1 ● | 1 ● | 1 ● | 1 ● | 9 | Good |
Locke [11] | 1 ● | 0 ○ | 1 ● | 1 ● | 1 ● | 1 ● | 1 ● | 1 ● | 1 ● | 8 | Good |
Abbott [2] | 1 ● | 1 ● | 1 ● | 1 ● | 0 ○ | 0 ○ | 1 ● | 1 ● | 1 ● | 7 | Fair |
Cristelli Brazil [60] | 1 ● | 0 ○ | 1 ● | 1 ● | 0 ○ | 0 ○ | 1 ● | 1 ● | 1 ● | 6 | Fair |
Cristelli Spain [60] | 1 ● | 0 ○ | 1 ● | 1 ● | 0 ○ | 0 ○ | 1 ● | 1 ● | 1 ● | 6 | Fair |
Mazuecos [61] | 1 ● | 1 ● | 1 ● | 1 ● | 0 ○ | 1 ● | 1 ● | 1 ● | 1 ● | 8 | Good |
Rosa [40] | 1 ● | 0 ○ | 1 ● | 1 ● | 0 ○ | 1 ● | 1 ● | 1 ● | 1 ● | 7 | Fair |
Vicari [30] | 1 ● | 1 ● | 1 ● | 1 ● | 0 ○ | 0 ○ | 1 ● | 1 ● | 1 ● | 7 | Fair |
Bossini [27] | 1 ● | 0 ○ | 1 ● | 1 ● | 0 ○ | 0 ○ | 1 ● | 1 ● | 1 ● | 6 | Fair |
Mazuecos [9] | 1 ● | 1 ● | 1 ● | 1 ● | 0 ○ | 1 ● | 1 ● | 1 ● | 1 ● | 8 | Good |
Gathogo [34] | 1 ● | 0 ○ | 1 ● | 1 ● | 0 ○ | 1 ● | 1 ● | 1 ● | 1 ● | 7 | Fair |
Malat [62] | 1 ● | 0 ○ | 1 ● | 1 ● | 0 ○ | 1 ● | 1 ● | 1 ● | 1 ● | 7 | Fair |
Sum ● | 29 | 8 | 29 | 29 | 3 | 9 | 29 | 29 | 29 | ||
Sum ○ | 0 | 21 | 0 | 0 | 26 | 20 | 0 | 0 | 0 | ||
Percent ● | 100 | 28 | 100 | 100 | 10 | 31 | 100 | 100 | 100 |