Skip to main content

Table 1 Randomized control trials determining time to initiate ART in HIV-infected patients with TB

From: Integrated therapy for HIV and tuberculosis

Study

TB characteristics

Median CD4 count

Study arms

Mortality difference

Country

ART regimen

(1A) SAPIT 1

Abdool Karim et al. NEJM 2010 [43]

Smear +ve pulmonary TB

150

Integrated vs. sequential

5 vs. 12 deaths/100 PYs

56 % lower in integrated arm

South Africa

ddI, 3TC, EFV

(1B) SAPIT 2

Abdool Karim et al. NEJM 2011 [44]

Smear +ve pulmonary TB

150

4 vs. 8–12 weeks

No differences of AIDS/death

Lower in only CD4 <50

8 vs. 26 deaths/100 PYs

South Africa

ddI, 3TC, EFV

(2) CAMELIA

Blanc et al. NEJM 2011 [42]

Smear +ve pulmonary TB

25

2 vs. 8 weeks

15 vs. 26 %

38 % lower in 2-week arm

Cambodia

d4T, 3TC, EFV

(3) STRIDE

Havlir et al.

NEJM 2011 [45]

Confirmed or probable pulmonary TB

77

<2 vs. 8–12 weeks

No differences of mortality

Lower in only CD4 <50

15 vs. 27 %

Multi-national

TDF/FTC, EFV

(4) TOROK

Torok et al. CID 2011 [49]

TB meningitis

41

<2 vs. 8 weeks

No differences of time to death

Vietnam

AZT, 3TC, EFV

(5) TIME

Manosuthi et al. JAIDS 2012 [46]

Confirmed or probable any TB

43

4 vs. 12 weeks

Have a tendency in CD4 <50

10 vs. 14 deaths/100 PYs

Thailand

TDF, 3TC, EFV

(6) TB-HAART

Mfinanga et al. Lancet ID 2014 [48]

Culture-confirmed TB

367

≤2 weeks vs. 6 months

No difference between early and late ART on composite endpoint of death, tuberculosis treatment failure, and recurrence

South Africa, Uganda, Zambia, Tanzania

AZT, 3TC, EFV